Overstock faces challenges following Bed Bath & Beyond rebranding
Overstock.com (NASDAQ: OSTK), the online furniture liquidator, is experiencing a significant drop in stock value following its rebranding to Bed Bath & Beyond (OTC: BBBYQ), despite initial investor enthusiasm. The company purchased Bed Bath & Beyond’s brand and intellectual property for $21.5 million in June 2023 and officially implemented the name change on August 1.
Following the acquisition announcement, Overstock’s stock surged 76% due to positive investor sentiment. However, this enthusiasm has since waned, with the stock plummeting 52% from August 1 to Thursday. A September 6 update on the company’s corporate identity transition revealed smaller than anticipated improvements in web traffic and active customer numbers, contributing to the decline.
Despite Bed Bath & Beyond’s brand-carrying advantages such as higher brand awareness and a stronger association with home goods, it also has drawbacks. The brand has experienced a period of decline which may have negatively impacted its value. Additionally, Overstock now faces stiff competition from retail giants like Amazon.com (NASDAQ: AMZN), Walmart (NYSE: WMT), and Target who offer services like same-day delivery or in-store pickup options that Overstock does not provide.
These competitors also have the capacity to undercut Overstock’s prices. While Bed Bath’s prices are currently competitive, this could be affecting profit margins as the company attempts to reposition itself in a saturated market.
In an attempt to regain customer loyalty, Overstock initiated a promotional campaign. The company estimates that Bed Bath had nearly 20 million active customers in its last year of operation, half of whom made at least one online purchase in the past year. At its peak, Bed Bath had nearly 40 million shoppers.
However, these efforts might weigh on profitability in the short term. There are concerns that customer acquisition will be slower than Overstock anticipates, potentially extending the investment phase beyond the expected few quarters.
Despite these challenges, Overstock’s strong balance sheet and solid cash reserves may help it weather the storm. The company is expected to become more efficient with its marketing expenses over time. While Overstock has inherited a well-known brand that could drive long-term growth, it has also inherited some of Bed Bath & Beyond’s significant challenges. Only time will reveal how these factors will balance out.